Understanding “Failing to Fail”
As Beischel (2024) describes, “failing to fail” often stems from good intentions. Teachers feel compassion, administrators fear low retention statistics, and systems prioritize optics over outcomes. Yet, as seen in Fern’s daughter’s case, such practices harm the very students they aim to protect.
The COVID-19 pandemic only amplified this tendency. During 2021, for example, one U.S. school district adopted a “No F Mandate,” pressuring teachers to pass absent or disengaged students (Wall, 2021).
These systemic failures mirror smaller-scale issues across Caribbean schools, where teachers often face administrative pressure, overcrowded classrooms, and minimal support for remediation.
Parent Voice and Powerlessness
Fern’s frustration — “I was telling them she needs to stay back … make her learn more” — reveals another layer of inequity: the power gap between parents and schools.
Tutwiler (2005) reminds educators that families living in poverty often feel marginalized within the system. Their concerns are heard but not acted upon, especially when the parent lacks advocacy networks or confidence to challenge authority.
Fern’s repeated helplessness — “they pass her … I don’t know why” — captures what many parents in low-income Bahamian and Jamaican communities express when promotion decisions seem detached from student readiness.
